"I use Grammarly's plagiarism check because copy-cats can never replicate the success and popularity of the original!"
Title-Confessionally Yours
Author-Jhoomur Bose
Publisher-Penguin(Metro reads)
Pages-216
Source-Personal Copy
Publisher-Harper Collins
Pages-230
Source-Personal Copy
Title-Confessionally Yours
Author-Jhoomur Bose
Publisher-Penguin(Metro reads)
Pages-216
Source-Personal Copy
‘Confessionally
Yours’(published by’ Penguin’ in their ‘Metro Reads’ series) is the kind of book which is not meant to be taken
seriously.After all,I picked up this book as I was looking for a
light,entertaining book to read during my two hour commute to Mumbai.The book
turned out to be a light read(chick-lit) indeed but what is entertaining?Well,only
in parts!
‘CY’ is
essentially the story of Polly Sharma,a junior probationary staff in a weekly
tabloid.She is constantly harassed by her boss(Leena a.k.a. ‘Comma’,who is a
bitch by the way)because of her inabilility to write ‘quality stuff’ for the
tabloid.To add to her woes,Polly feels that her husband(Siddharth)doesn’t love
her as she hasn’t conceived even after 10 months of marital life.In short,her
life(both personal and professional) is totally messed and that is when she
gets an offer to write an ‘expose’ on an anonymous blogger who is the toast of
the season.Loosely based on some real life incidents(even the title of this
book has a striking resemblance to a real life blog),the novel traces the life
of Polly Sharma and her struggles to break free from the ‘door- mat tag’ which
seems to have stuck to her eternally.
The basic
problem with the book is that there is nothing here which we haven’t read or
seen before.Most of the twists fall flat and so does the writer’s attempt to take
a satirical look at the life as a journo in a tabloid. The references to Meenakshi
Reddy Madhavan’s titillating blog (the compulssive confessor) and her first
book deal are difficult to overlook.At times,I even got the feeling that this
book wouldn’t have seen the light of the day if miss reddy’s blog hadn’t been
there at the first place.Moreover so many things are left un-explained(what was
the connection between Trishala and Leena?,why did ‘her friend’ try to sabotage
Polly’s career?)but then as I had said before,this is one book which is not
meant to be taken seriously.
Verdict-Mediocre
stuff!But if you are desperately looking for a half-decent desi chick-lit,you
can still give this a try! Rating-2/5
Title-Frankly Spooking
Author-Sriramana MuliyaPublisher-Harper Collins
Pages-230
Source-Personal Copy
'Frankly
spooking' is a rather forgettable anthology of horror stories written by blogger-turned-
author Sriramana Muliya.The sole reason for me buying this book was the good
press that this book had elicited.Even a couple of bloggers had written really
nice things about this work of horror fiction. The fact that this is one of the
rare occasions in which an Indian writer had decided to try his hand at writing
horror fiction,made me all the more kicked up about this work and I couldn’t
resist ordering a copy of this book online.(though I really felt that it was a
bit over priced at 295 INR!).But I am sorry to say that the book left me sorely
disappointed.First and foremost,’Frankly spooking’ never really succeeded in
scaring me.What’s even worse is that Icouldn’t find anything which was even
remotely original about any of the stories in the book.In an attempt to spook
the reader,Sriramana inadvertently packs in every other horror film clichés(agreed,the
tales don’t have a woman in white saree making her appearance every now and
then,but I never said ‘Bollywood clichés’,did I?) and thereby lets down the discerning reader(
horror fiction fanatics).Most of the stories and even the situations used in
them reek of familiarity and have a been there,read that feel to it.Though
there are about two dozen stories in the book,I felt that only two had some
potential(‘team player’ and ‘blogosphere’) but that too were spoilt by bland,un-imaginative
and abrupt ending.
Verdict-On
the whole,’Frankly Spooking’ was a big disappointment.The author deserves
praise for attempting something new but not all great ideas translate to
desired results.What say you?Rating- 2/5.
-nikhimenon
-nikhimenon
5 comments:
Thank you Nikhilesh for the constructive review. Every work is a learning, and we must strive to do better. And it helps immensely to know the pitfalls. Thank you. :)
@phatichar..
I am sorry if my review sounded a bit harsh.But then,my expectations were too high.All the best for your future works.
Hey, its ok. You wrote your viewpoint, please don't apologize. Yes expectations differ because perceptions differ. Stories are such. It's perfectly ok! Thanks for reading and taking the time to review. :)
sounds good
Post a Comment